It’s that time of year again…time to rank the top 10 shows of 2008. Of course, the usual caveat: this only includes shows which I watched, which this year was only about 20, so it was a kind of slow year for me. Nevertheless, this list still boasts a pretty impressive list of shows.
10. Birdy the Mighty: Decode
Isn’t it every boy’s dream to have easy access to a female body? Well, Tsutomu in theory is living that dream, except the girl is in control of the body because she accidentally destroyed his. Oops! What results is a mix of action and comedy which is pretty well executed all told, with Tsutomu frequently getting freaked out by Birdy’s alien ways.
Two things held this series back: animation, which wasn’t exactly top-notch, and the fact that, after Tsutomu gets his body back, they find away in the end to make him and Birdy share bodies again. I guess Tsutomu just thinks that he can be immortal as long as Birdy is there to absorb him whenever he takes a notion to destroy his body. The one minus that this sets up is that it implies that the gimmick of them changing bodies is the only real draw of the show, and the writer’s belief that they can’t have a successful show without that gimmick. I’m not sure that bodes well for the second season, but that doesn’t necessarily impact this season all that much.
Kurenai ekes into the top 10 list by doing a reasonably good job at two things: writing and animation. Perhaps the best part of this series is watching the struggle and growth of the characters as they have to adapt to new environments, particularly Shinkuro, who is trying to find his true strength, and Murasaki, who has to adapt to living out in the “real world” now, all while having a powerful family chasing after them.
However, this show has a few weaknesses as well. First, the show’s conclusion in a sense made a compromise with the devil – accommodating an evil family which probably shouldn’t be accommodated in the least, taking the air out of a lot of what everyone was fighting for and protecting throughout the show. Second, I think overall this series, despite it’s overall good writing, missed some chances to turn Kurenai from simply a good series into a great series. The theme music, particularly the opening theme, also didn’t seem to match the show at all and just seemed kind of weird. However, overall it was still a pretty good show.
8. The Secret of Haruka Nogizaka
The mantle of “Otaku Show of the Year” probably goes out to The Secret of Haruka Nogizaka this year as there are anime references galore, as well as every otaku’s dream: A girl otaku. A hot girl otaku. A hot, popular girl otaku. A hot, popular girl otaku who likes you because you don’t shun her once you discover her secret of being an otaku. A hot, popular girl otaku who likes you because you don’t shun her once you discover her secret of being an otaku and who likes to cosplay as Shana. I mean, can it get any better than that?
I guess one of the nice things about this show, as opposed to something like, say, Lucky Star, is “normal people can be otaku too.” However outwardly odd Konota is in Lucky Star is how outwardly normal Haruka is in Secret. Yes, she illicitly sneaks off to Akihabara every now and then, but overall she’s your normal high schooler. Of course, the series is also hilarious on top of all of this too. The main problem is that it’s a little thin in the plot department, but given that the purpose of this series is to have fun, and I had fun watching it, it goes into the top 10 list.
7. Shion no Ou (2nd half)
The conclusion of Shion no Ou dealt with the big shogi tournament being sponsored by Satoru, Hani-meijin’s brother, from the start of the final state of the tournament where the 9 bracket winners plus 3 of the bracket runner-ups face off in a 12-person bracket to determine the winner of the tournament. As a result, a few of the games played last through multiple episodes, but the writers are able to keep the show interesting nevertheless. Increasing the attention on solving the mystery of who solved Shion’s parents just adds more intrigue into the show as well.
The main weakness of this show is that, if watching people play shogi bores you to death, then this show may not be for you, as a lot of time is spent with the characters playing. I thought that the show did a pretty good job keeping the episodes interesting despite this, but I can easily see if people disagree with that. However, overall I thought the conclusion to Shion was pretty well executed.
6. Nijuu Mensou no Musume
I should note before starting: fansubs have only come out for 20 of 22 episodes. However, I felt that it was complete enough that I could put it in the rankings.
Having said that, Nijuu Mensou is a show with a very good premise and animation. It’s set in the mid-20th century – an era which you don’t see a lot of anime shows set in, so it is unusual in that aspect. And Twenty Faces himself makes this series pretty compelling, to say nothing about Chiko, his all-but-adoptive daughter and title character.
Two things keep Nijuu Mensou from being a truly great show however: reuse of the “OMG Twenty Faces died! Oh, nevermind!” gimmick probably one too many times, and the fact that the series goes into stranger territory than I was expecting for the show. Nevertheless, Nijuu Mensou still puts together a very solid performance.
5. Soul Eater (first 3/4)
Soul Eater is a very fascinating show. It’s quite different from just about anything else, yet Bones is able to pull it off pretty well. However, the thing that really drives Soul Eater is the wealth of unique characters. While some of the character development is a little odd (Maka and Soul don’t seem to be very powerful for a pair to have almost created a Death Scythe – especially with only six Death Scythes existing the world, suggesting that it’s a very hard thing to accomplish), it is generally pretty good. All three pairs are compelling in their own unique ways.
If I have one beef with this series (actually two), it’s that it veered off it’s original premise – gathering 99 kishin eggs and one witch’s soul – pretty quickly, and it has a bad habit of drawing things out to death (how many episodes did it take to get through the battle at Shibusen, anyway?) However, all told, Soul Eater still puts in a very solid performance.
4. CLANNAD (2nd half) / CLANNAD: After Story (1st half)
For the second straight year, CLANNAD comes in at #4 in the list. Since the first series of CLANNAD exited it’s “four-episodes-an-arc” mode and got more into mixing arcs or telling an overarching story, and since we got into CLANNAD: After Story which, until the lastest episodes, centered around more minor characters, this series has fallen in favor a little bit (though obviously not very much).
CLANNAD is still very much the class of both 2007 and 2008, and presumably will contend for a top spot on this list in 2009 as well. We might not be in arcs for the main girls, but the storytelling is still pretty good, if not a little slow going at this point, which is why it only comes in 4th on the list.
3. Toradora! (1st half)
The choice between 2nd and 3rd was very close, and I think the fact that Toradora was in it’s first half while the 2nd placing show was in it’s concluding half was the main reason why Toradora came in at #3.
Toradora is a very, very good show – one which I think may challenge for the #1 spot in 2009 if they keep up what they’re doing in the first half into the 2nd half of the show. While Toradora has a somewhat familiar flavor – it is, afterall, essentially a slice-of-life harem show – there is still something about it and (especially) it’s characters which makes it different, and a lot better than shows that it might be compared to. It pulls off good drama and comedy almost simultaneously and still gets in some good character exploration and storytelling to boot.
2. Shakugan no Shana II (2nd half)
The first half of this show didn’t even grace the top 10 list in 2007, just to show how far it came in the second half of the series. We started with Pheles, then moved to Sabrac, then on to the Bal Masqué’s ultimate plan at the end. There was hardly time to breathe and Shana and friends moved from one major confrontation to the next, making the second half of Shakugan no Shana II one of the best action shows in quite a while, not just 2008.
1. ef – a tale of melodies
Improving on it’s sibling’s 3rd place finish last year, ef – a tale of melodies was nothing short of epic. And to think that 40% of this show (the Kuze/Mizuki arc) was pretty dull, that just shows how good the other 60% of the show (the Yuu/Yuuko) arc was. If the entire show was just that arc, ef – a tale of melodies would not only contend for best show of 2008, but also perhaps for best show, period.
This show had (almost) everything – romance, drama, shocking plot twists, and more. You almost couldn’t help but me drawn into the show. And the fact that the show isn’t afraid to put your heart at ease, only to tear it out in the next episode just makes this show all that much better.